Interview: Paul Rees on leaving the NPA to ‘clamp down on racism’ at nursing regulator

'Toxic’ and ‘dysfunctional’: What did the independent review into the nursing regulator find?
An independent review of the UK’s nursing regulator in 2024 identified a ‘dangerously toxic culture’ in which bullying, racism and burnout are putting nurses and the public at risk.
The damning report called for an ‘urgent turnaround plan’ to ‘stop a dysfunctional culture’ at the NMC.
Led by former public prosecutor Nazir Afzal, with Rise Associates, the review warned of an NMC workforce that is ‘really struggling’ and an environment where ‘poor judgement, toxic behaviours and paralysis is affecting decision-making’.
Related Article: Anticoagulant Inhixa recalled due to typo
And it revealed serious concerns around the way in which fitness to practise (FtP) cases are handled, including that action was being taken ‘against good nurses’ while ‘bad nurses get away with it’.
At the time, the NMC issued an apology and promised action to ‘deliver a culture change programme’ following a series of recommendations in the report, including more investment in people, a faster screening process to tackle complaints, a new safeguarding hub and increased black and ethnic minority managers so they can better understand the communities they serve.
Rise Associates and Mr Afzal were commissioned to complete the independent cultural review of the NMC in January 2024, following a series of disclosures by a whistleblower in 2023, who accused the NMC of a ‘deep seated toxic culture’.
Former NMC chief executive and registrar Andrea Sutcliffe stepped down from her role just before the report's publication due to ill-health.
She said at the time: ‘Having received the draft of this important report three weeks after my decision to step down, I know there is powerful testimony from colleagues sharing their stories about racism, discrimination and bullying and their views of the NMC. It’s extremely important for the organisation to truly listen and respond.'
Related Article: Interview: Pharmacy First saves time, prevents escalation, and frees up capacity
Ms Sutcliffe was replaced on an interim basis by Dawn Brodrick in July 2024, who then resigned four days after her appointment was announced following concerns raised around her reported links to a high-profile discrimination case while working at an NHS trust.
NMC executive director of resources and technology services Helen Herniman then started in an acting capacity some days later.
In October 2024, the NMC appointed equality, diversity and inclusion (EDI) advisor Mac Alonge to its executive board and council.
Related Article: New GPhC chief standards officer appointed
And in November 2024, it was announced that Paul Rees would take on the post for a period of 12 months from 20 January 2025.
The above reporting on the 2024 independent review into the NMC was first published by Madeleine Anderson at our sister title Nursing in Practice.
Have your say
Please add your comment in the box below. You can include links, but HTML is not permitted. Please note that comments are not moderated before publication and the views expressed are those of the user and do not reflect the views of The Pharmacist. Remember that submission of comments is governed by our Terms and Conditions. You can also read our full guidelines on article comments here – but please be aware that you are legally liable for any libellous or offensive comments that you make. If you have a complaint about a comment or are concerned that a comment breaches our terms and conditions, please use the ‘Report this comment’ function to alert our web team.